Saturday, September 03, 2016

Twenty-third Sunday in Ordinary Time

 
Catechism Links[1]
CCC 273, 300, 314: God’s transcendence
CCC 36-43: knowledge of God according to the Church
CCC 2544: prefer Christ to all else
CCC 914-919, 93-932: following Christ in consecrated life

“Christ Carrying the Cross” 
by Cecchino del Salviati, 1540s
 
 
Commentary:
 
Reading 1: Wisdom 9:13-18b
 
Commentary on Wis 9:13-18b
 
This selection is part of what is known as Solomon’s Prayer for Wisdom (see also 1 Kings 3:6-9; 1 Chronicles 1:8-10). In it the author asks the ancient question: “Who can divine the will of the Lord?” It is asked rhetorically, in that the question is answered. We mortals alone cannot understand God's will. We are not pure spirit, nor are we in communion with God. Our only salvation is that God sent the Holy Spirit who shows us what pleases God, and leads us on the right paths.
 
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Responsorial Psalm: Psalm 90:3-4, 5-6, 12-13, 14-17
 
R. (1) In every age, O Lord, you have been our refuge.
 
 
The psalm in its entirety is a communal lament.  The strophes in this selection reflect on the mortality of humanity, and the brevity of human life. (It is also an example of the human understanding that God’s immortal view of time is not like ours.) 
 
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Reading II: Philemon 9-10, 12-17
 
Commentary on Phmn 9-10, 12-17
 
The passage from St. Paul’s Letter to Philemon is his plea (not command) for the runaway slave (and perhaps thief), Onesimus. The apostle alludes to Onesimus’ conversion (whose father I have become in my imprisonment). In the strongest possible terms, he lets the slave’s former master know that he (St. Paul) considers him (Onesimus) to be a brother in the Gospel of Christ, rather than a slave. The Apostle then encourages the community at Colossae, to which the letter is directed, to accept his return on that basis.
 
CCC: Phmn 16 2414
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Gospel: Luke 14:25-33
 
Commentary on Lk 14:25-33
 
The Lord, perhaps in an action intended to identify those who had the zeal to be true disciples, tells the crowd of the necessity of total dedication to the call to discipleship. They had seen his recent miracles of healing, and were, no doubt, hoping to learn wisdom from him.
 
He tells them that they must place their love of God first, before family and even their own lives. He tells them, through two examples – the construction of the tower and the evaluation of the battle – that they must measure the sacrifice needed to be his follower. He punctuates his statement by telling them they must “renounce” all their possessions to follow him.
 
CCC: Lk 14:26 1618; Lk 14:33 2544
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Homily:
 
When the Gospel was proclaimed I suspect many of us reacted the same way saying: “That’s not a very uplifting piece of scripture. …“If anyone comes to me without hating his father and mother, wife and children, brothers and sisters, and even his own life, he cannot be my disciple.”  Where is the Lord coming from with that?  Luke goes on to quote the Lord as saying: “Whoever does not carry his own cross and come after me cannot be my disciple.”
 
First, let’s address St. Luke’s use of the word “hate.”  In almost all English translations of the scripture the Latin words “non odit” are translated as “hate not.”  Many scripture scholars look at the parallel passage in St. Matthew’s Gospel for a sense of what that word means in this context, since it is so unlikely that our Lord actually used the word hate.  St. Matthew’s Gospel says “Whoever loves father or mother more than me…” (Matthew 10:37ff).  Because of this cross- reference many scholars believe the term was used idiomatically and meant “loved less.”
 
Moving beyond the word that caused us to sit up and pay attention, what is the Lord really saying?  Let’s look at the situation in which Jesus found himself.  He had been preaching and healing the sick for some time now, and was becoming famous.  We were told at the beginning of the Gospel passage that “great crowds were traveling with Jesus.”  We pose this question to you: do you think these “great crowds” that were following Jesus [the miracle worker] were doing so because of his compelling message about the Kingdom of God?  Almost certainly, most people were there for the entertainment value, out of curiosity, or even because they thought it was a good thing to do.
 
Jesus knew all of this.  So he made a decision to tell the crowds what was expected of them if they wanted to continue to traipse around the countryside with him, following along as was the custom.  So he turned and asked them, through example, if they are willing to pay the price that must be paid to be his disciples.  Were they willing to give up everything they found important in their lives and to undergo the persecution Jesus knew was coming in order to follow him?  We can imagine the response, can’t we?  There was likely a rapid exit for a majority of those crowds when they heard him telling them that nothing in the world could be as important as his Father’s Kingdom.  That price would have been too much for all but the most devout and serious members of the crowd.
 
It is a very hard thing we are being asked to do by this Gospel.  Jesus asks the crowds then, and us now, if we have calculated the price of following Jesus.  He begs us to think carefully about our answers because, whether we like it or not, visibly following the Lord today means that we are indeed picking up our cross to take the path of discipleship.  Acting on the Gospel message in today’s society in an obvious way (e.g. making it clear that the charitable actions, our outspoken defense of a just economic system, or our defense of religious freedom is based upon our Christian faith) is becoming dangerous.
 
That is the Gospel question we are being asked to consider today.  Of course we have support in considering our answer.  We are reminded, for instance in the reading from the Book of Wisdom, that in things of the soul, the Holy Spirit will guide us on straight paths.  That means, however, we must look to the Holy Spirit for guidance. We are also reminded by St. Paul as he writes on behalf of Onesimus, that we are not alone; there are many others who will stand with us in the cause of discipleship.
 
But let us not sugarcoat the real message.  The price the Lord demands for discipleship is complete dedication to him, subordinating all other worldly interests to love of God, his Son, and the Holy Spirit.  We are asked the question he asked St. Peter on the shore of the Sea of Tiberias after his resurrection (John 21:15-19). Do you recall what the Lord asked, three times?  He asked St. Peter if he loved him.  This is how St. Peter’s exchange was concluded.  It will help us as we consider this message today:
 
“Amen, amen, I say to you, when you were younger, you used to dress yourself and go where you wanted; but when you grow old, you will stretch out your hands, and someone else will dress you and lead you where you do not want to go.”
 
He said this signifying by what kind of death he would glorify God. And when he had said this, he said to him, “Follow me.”
 
Pax


[1] Catechism links are taken from the Homiletic Directory, Published by the Congregation for Divine Worship and the Discipline of the Sacraments, 29 June 2014
[2] The picture used today is “Christ Carrying the Cross” by Cecchino del Salviati, 1540s
 

Friday, September 02, 2016

Memorial of Saint Gregory the Great, Pope and Doctor of the Church

 
"Saint Gregory the Great" 
by Jacopo Vignali, c. 1630
 
 
 
Commentary:
 
 
Commentary on 1 Cor 4:6b-15
 
This reading is part of an introduction to St. Paul’s discourse on divisions in the community. He begins with an individual instruction:”That you may learn from us not to go beyond what is written: the words 'to go' are not in the Greek, but have here been added as the minimum necessary to elicit sense from this difficult passage. It probably means that the Corinthians should avoid the false wisdom of vain speculation, contenting themselves with Paul's proclamation of the cross, which is the fulfillment of God's promises in the Old Testament (what is written). Inflated with pride: literally, 'puffed up,' i.e., arrogant, filled with a sense of self-importance.[4]”
 
St. Paul makes three ironic statements as to the benefits the Corinthians have already received (“satisfied”, “rich”, “kings”). These are really rhetorical questions that get at a general tendency by this community to have an exaggerated sense and understanding of the eschaton, or the end times (e.g. the imminent return and rapture).
 
St. Thomas Aquinas comments on this passage as follows: "The Apostle here considers four types of pride: the first, when one thinks that what one has does not come from God [...]; the second, which is similar, when one thinks that one has done everything on one's own merit; the third, when one boasts of having something which one does not in fact have [...]; the fourth, when one despises others and is concerned only about oneself" ("Commentary on 1 Cor, ad loc.").[5]
 
The apostle continues this selection with a description of the conditions in which the Apostles (himself included) are viewed and treated by the world. He contrasts the difficulty they encounter with the ease and comfort of those who believe (in error) that they have achieved a state of glory, and bask in the light of Christ. The description of the suffering of the Apostles St. Paul provides, “…place the apostles in the class of those to whom the beatitudes promise future relief (Matthew 5:3-11; Luke 6:20-23); whereas the Corinthians' image of themselves as "already" filled, rich, ruling (1 Corinthians 4:8), as wise, strong, and honored (1 Corinthians 4:10) places them paradoxically in the position of those whom the woes threaten with future undoing (Luke 6:24-26). They have lost sight of the fact that the reversal is predicted for the future.[6]”
 
Almost as if to take the sting out of his ironically charged chastisement, St. Paul describes his relation to them as a “father” who teaches his children through his lived example.
 
CCC: 1 Cor 4:7 224
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Responsorial Psalm: Psalm 145:17-18, 19-20, 21
 
R. (18) The Lord is near to all who call upon him.
 
Commentary on Ps 145:17-18, 19-20, 21
 
Psalm 145 is a hymn of praise. These strophes call on the faithful to give thanks to God for opening the gates of his Heavenly Kingdom. They continue praising God for his justice and his creating hand.
 
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Gospel:  Luke 6:1-5
 
Commentary on Lk 6:1-5
 
The Pharisees attack the disciples because they picked some grain to eat on the sabbath. In Pharisaic Law, that act is considered work, and is forbidden on the Lord’s Day. The Lord reinterprets their Law, citing the First Book of Samuel (1 Samuel 21:2-7) and Leviticus (Leviticus 24:8). The implication of his final statement in this passage is clear to us. “The ultimate justification for the disciples' violation of the sabbath rest is that Jesus, the Son of Man, has supreme authority over the law.[7]”
 
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Reflection:
 
There is a management methodology highly praised in business circles that states: If you want to achieve an organizational goal, you need to manage the team as if that goal had already been achieved. Stated another way this means, if you want to have something occur, behave as if it already had. Where people often find difficulty with this is when they forget they are working toward an end result, and begin to think they have already made the journey and have arrived. Those who have fallen into that trap are often seen as arrogant or (a favorite description being used in election campaign rhetoric) “out of touch with reality.”
 
St. Paul has observed this flaw in the faith community at Corinth. He realized that if the people who believe they have already achieved an enlightened or beatified state as a consequence of their adoption in the Lord continue down this path, real harm will be caused in the development of the Christian Community, and their true faith journey. He challenges them about their attitudes. He contrasts the relative ease and peace of their self-imposed idyllic faith to the difficult and gritty life of the Apostles, who are propagating the Gospel (himself included).
 
The passage we are given is a prelude to his deeper attack on divisions in the Body of Christ, but these opening remarks have their own lesson for us. Those of us who are working hard at developing our own spiritual center, trying to walk closely with Christ and God, must never think we are somehow better than those who struggle mightily, but are caught up so deeply in the net of the world’s entanglements that they cannot even see the light of Christ (or so it might seem to us). We must remember the model Christ has provided: the humility with which he led us when he walked among us as a man.
 
It is easy to see the trap the Corinthians fell into. They were so taken with the bliss that will come with the perfect communion with God that is his ultimate promise, that they began to act as if it were imminent, and forgot the difficult journey required to get to that place. We must always remember that our mission in this life is to walk the hard path, the humble path, the dusty path that was walked with Christ by those disciples on the road to Emmaus. We have not arrived. Much of our journey lies ahead of us, and we must constantly invite those we meet along the way to join us.
 
Pax


[2] The picture used today is "Saint Gregory the Great" by Jacopo Vignali, c. 1630
 
[4] See NAB footnote on 1 Corinthians 4:6
[5] Letters of St. Paul , The Navarre Bible, Four Courts Press, 2003
[6] See NAB footnote on 1 Corinthians 4:9-13
[7] See NAB footnote on Matthew 12:1-8

Thursday, September 01, 2016

Friday of the Twenty-second Week in Ordinary Time

 
“Blessing Christ and Praying Virgin” by Master of Flémalle, c. 1424
 
 
 
Commentary:
 
Reading 1: 1 Corinthians 4:1-5
 
Commentary on 1 Cor 4:1-5

This selection is part of St. Paul’s pre-oration regarding the need for unity in the church in Corinth. In this concluding section, the Apostle calls upon the community to be faithful to the teachings passed on to it. He speaks of Christian Wisdom with an exhortation to the community not to pass judgment on their leaders. He summarizes his thought with the statement: "Thus should one regard us: as servants of Christ and stewards of the mysteries of God." The words St. Paul uses to describe the roles are, in the first instance: “servants of Christ,” hypÄ“retÄ“s, a word that designated rowers on the lowest rank of a galley, later coming to mean assistant or helper. The word “stewards” (or managers) was oikonomos, a name given to servants put in charge of their master’s property.

He goes on to exhort them not to pass judgment upon each other, rather to follow his own example of being non-judgmental, even about his own actions. He concludes by reminding them that, at the “appointed time” (referring to the eschaton), the Lord will reveal all motives of the human heart and judgment will be passed.
 
CCC: 1 Cor 4:1 859, 1117; 1 Cor 4:5 678
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Responsorial Psalm: Psalm 37:3-4, 5-6, 27-28, 39-40
 
R. (39a) The salvation of the just comes from the Lord.
 
 
Psalm 37, a lament, continues the plea to be faithful to God and remain steadfast in the time of adversity. The psalmist adds a call for repentance, a return to righteousness. Failure to do so brings death. But those who take refuge in the Lord, and remain steadfast in their faith, God saves.
 
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Gospel: Luke 5:33-39
 
Commentary on Lk 5:33-39

In this exchange between Jesus and the Pharisees, we see the liberal use of metaphors to describe a new relationship.  There is a new covenant, but it is related to the old. The bridal metaphor clearly establishes a relationship between God and man, different from that expressed in the Hebrew tradition. God and man are in a love relationship, as opposed to God being superior to man and man subservient to God.
 
The Lord uses the metaphors of the new and old cloth, and the new and old wine skins, to illustrate that this Gospel message cannot be grafted onto Mosaic Law, but it becomes something entirely new. Attempting to hold both views is not possible; it will destroy both. (It is likely that St. Luke actually re-wrote the new vs. old cloth parable, also found in St. Mark’s Gospel - Mark 2:19ff.)
 
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Reflection:
 
“The old is good.” St. Luke sees the difficulty many members of his audience, especially the Pharisees, are having in accepting the idea that Christ came to fulfill the Law and the Prophets. They have had the “old wine” of these traditions and beliefs for their entire lives, and the traditions they inherited were passed down from generation upon generation, during which time they gained such rigidity of form and substance that they seemed indestructible.
 
The great irony is that it was for that very purpose God sent his Son into the world. The people to whom God had revealed himself in the signs and wonders in the age of Abraham, Isaac and Jacob, the great Exodus facilitated by Moses, had adopted traditions and they had taken upon themselves a life of their own. The acts themselves had become the object of worship, rather than God at whom they all pointed.
 
Through the ages God had sought to change this, to reveal himself and his will by sending the prophets: Jeremiah, Isaiah, Hosea and all those great instruments of God.  They cried out to the people, telling them, among other things, that God did not want sacrifices and holocaust. His intention was not to smell the burning flesh of the sacrificial altar.  His desire was the conversion of heart (see especially Psalm 51:18-19). He called to them to love each other and in doing so love him all the more. But the Old Wine was good.
 
The saying of Jesus about the old and new wineskins has a lesson for us as well. We must never become so rooted in our personal traditions that we fail to see what the Holy Spirit does in our midst. God calls us to constant conversion. That means change, and change is always difficult. The old wine, the wine to which we have become accustomed always tastes good. The new wine of conversion needs some getting used to.
 
Today our prayer is this, that even as we savor the old wine that is good, we are constantly ready to accept the new wine of conversion, inviting us deeper into the will of God and his call to us.
 
Pax


[1] The picture used today is “Blessing Christ and Praying Virgin” by Master of Flémalle, c. 1424